San Bernardino County Board of Education group photograph

141 Appeals of Expulsions from School Districts within the County

If a pupil is expelled from a school district (hereinafter “district”), the pupil may file an appeal with the County Board of Education (hereinafter “County Board”) at the office of the San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools, which written appeal shall be filed within thirty (30) calendar days following the decision of the district governing board to expel. The written notice of appeal shall contain the following information: {E.C. 48919}

a. Name of expelled pupil

b. Name of appellant

c. Relationship of appellant to expelled pupil (parent, guardian, self)

d. Address and telephone number of appellant

e. Name of respondent school board

f. Date of respondent school board’s action to expel

g. Grounds upon which the appeal is based.

Upon receipt of a written expulsion appeal containing the information above, the office of the San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools will promptly forward a copy of the expulsion appeal to members of the County Board.

The County Board shall subsequently hold a hearing thereon and render its decision. Whenever the word “pupil” is used in this County Board Policy, it shall include a pupil's parent or guardian, legal counsel, or advocate.

1. Requests for a hearing before the County Board shall be in writing and must be received in the Office of the San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools at least fifteen (15) working days prior to the regular meeting of the County Board to be considered at that meeting. The pupil shall submit a request for a copy of the written transcript (a complete and exact typewritten transcription of the tape of the expulsion hearing prepared by the district) and supporting documents concerning the expulsion from the district simultaneously with the filing of the notice of appeal with the County Board. The district shall provide the pupil with the transcription, supporting documents, and records within ten (10) school days following the pupil's request. The pupil shall file one (1) copy of these records with the County Board.

2. It is the responsibility of the pupil to provide, at least five (5) working days prior to the hearing, one (1) copy of a complete written transcript of the hearing before and prepared by the district.

The cost of such transcript shall be borne by the pupil except where:

h. The pupil certifies to the district that he or she cannot reasonably afford the cost because of limited income or exceptional necessary expenses, or both.

i. The County Board reverses the decision of the district board in which case the County Board shall require the district board to reimburse the pupil for the cost of such transcription.

3. At the regular meeting of the County Board, the Board shall hold the hearing or set the time and place when such hearing shall be held.

The hearing shall be held within twenty (20) school days following the filing of a request under this section and the County Board shall render a decision within three (3) school days of the hearing, unless the pupil requests a postponement. {E.C. 48919}

Requests for postponements may be made by either party and shall be directed to the Secretary to the Board. The Secretary to the County Board shall grant a postponement in the following cases:

a. Request by the Pupil for a Postponement. The pupil may request one postponement by means of a written notice at least forty-eight (48) hours in advance. The Secretary to the Board shall upon receipt of said request reset the hearing date to the next regularly scheduled Board meeting date and shall immediately notify all parties in writing of the new hearing date.

b. Subject to the limitations set forth in 3.a above, the Board may grant a postponement at any time should it determine that such postponement is necessary to avoid injustice.

c. Hearings shall commence promptly at the time designated by the County Board. If good cause prevents such an appearance, notification of such good cause shall be given to the County Board at least twenty (20) minutes prior to the hearing time designated. Absent exceptional circumstances, if the pupil does not appear at the designated time, or within twenty (20) minutes thereafter, the appeal shall be deemed withdrawn and the decision of the district board affirmed.

4. The County Board shall hear the appeal in closed session unless the pupil requests in writing, at least five (5) days prior to the date of the hearing, that the hearing be a public meeting. Upon the timely submission of a request for a public meeting, the County Board shall be required to honor the request.

Whether the hearing is conducted in closed or public session, the Board shall meet in closed session for the purpose of deliberations. The attorney for the Board may attend such closed session. If the County Board admits any representative of the pupil or the school district into deliberations, the County Board shall, at the same time, admit representatives from the opposing party.

5. An electronic recording of the hearing shall be made and preserved for a period of three (3) years.

6. The County Board shall determine the appeal upon the record (i.e., transcription and other supporting documents) of the hearing before the district board, together with any applicable documentation or regulations as may be ordered. No other evidence may be heard except in the rare case where a de novo proceeding is held. A de novo proceeding is where the County Board actually conducts a new expulsion hearing as if the hearing before the district board had never occurred. Such de novo hearings are held only in exceptional cases.

Normally all appeals before the County Board are limited to a review of the record of the hearing before the district board, supplemented by oral argument.

7. The review by the County Board shall be limited to the following questions:

a. Whether the district board acted without or in excess of its jurisdiction. A proceeding without or in excess of jurisdiction includes, but is not limited to, a situation where an expulsion hearing is not commenced within the time periods prescribed by the Education Code, a situation where an expulsion order is not based upon legal grounds for expulsion, or a situation involving acts not related to school activity or attendance.

b. Whether there was a fair hearing before the district board.

c. Whether there was a prejudicial abuse of discretion in the hearing.

An abuse of discretion is established in any of the following situations:

1. If district officials have not met the procedural requirements of the Education Code;

2. If the decision to expel a pupil is not supported by the findings of the district board;

3. If the findings are not supported by the evidence.

The County Board may not reverse the decision of the district board to expel a pupil based upon a finding of an abuse of discretion unless the County Board also determines that the abuse of discretion was prejudicial.

d. Whether there is relevant and material evidence, which, in the exercise of reasonable diligence, could not have been produced or which was improperly excluded at the hearing before the district board.

8. The decision of the County Board shall be limited as follows:

a. Where the County Board finds that relevant and material evidence exists which, in the exercise of reasonable diligence, could not have been produced or which was improperly excluded at the hearing before the district board, it may do either of the following:

1. Remand the matter to the district board for reconsideration and may in addition order the pupil reinstated pending such reconsideration; or, instead,

2. In rare cases grant a hearing de novo upon reasonable notice thereof to the pupil and to the district board. A hearing de novo or new hearing is described in paragraph 6 of this appeal policy.

b. If the County Board determines that the decision of the governing board is not supported by the findings required to be made by Section 48915, but evidence supporting the required findings exists in the record of the proceedings, the county board shall remand the matter to the governing board for adoption of the required findings. This remand for the adoption and inclusion of the required findings shall not result in an additional hearing pursuant to Section 48918, except that final action to expel the pupil based on the revised findings of fact shall meet all requirements of subdivisions (j) and (k) of Section 48918.

c. In all other cases, the County Board shall enter an order either affirming or reversing the decision of the district board. In any case in which the County Board enters a decision reversing the district board, the County Board may direct the district board to expunge the record of the pupil and the records of the district of any references to the expulsion action and such expulsion shall be deemed not to have occurred.

9. The decision of the County Board shall be final and binding upon the pupil and upon the district board. The final order of the County Board shall be in writing and shall be delivered as quickly as possible to the pupil and to the district board by personal service or by certified mail. The order shall become final when rendered.

Amended 12/06/04, 08/03/15, 11/01/21, 05/13/24
Reviewed 07/13/15
Amended and Adopted 01/03/17, 12/13/21